This PR adds TLSv1.3 support for the negotiated protocol and cipher in run_server_preference(). This mostly addresses #893, however, run_server_preference() will not work with a TLSv1.3-only server as it will fail when trying to determine whether the server has a cipher order.
Note that with this PR run_server_preference() will not always provide consistent results when testing a server that does not support TLSv1.3 using a version of OpenSSL prior to 1.1.1. If it is determined before running run_server_preference() (using run_protocols()) that the server does not support TLSv1.3, then run_server_preference() will using OpenSSL to determine the negotiated protocol and cipher. However, if it has not yet been determined that the server does not support TLSv1.3, then run_server_preference() will use tls_sockets(), which tries to simulate OpenSSL 1.1.1. Since the list of cipher lists sent will differ the negotiated cipher will sometimes differ. In addition, when a cipher suite that uses an ephemeral ECDH key is selected, the negotiated curve is sometimes different.
This PR fixes#901. When $OPENSSL_TIMEOUT is set and mass testing is being performed, this PR changes find_openssl_binary() so that only child instances modify $OPENSSL to add the call to timeout.
This PR also changes the warning in case $OPENSSL_TIMEOUT is set and the timeout binary cannot be found so that the warning message is printed even if $WARNINGS is "off" or "batch".
When the server's response to the ClientHello message (i.e., the ServerHello, Certificate, ServerHelloDone) is split across more than one packet, the current call to tls_sockets() in run_heartbleed() only retrieves the first packet. As a result, sometimes when run_heartbleed() believes that it is reading the response to the Heartbleed payload it is actually reading the continuation of the response to the ClientHello message.
This PR fixes the problem by indicating in the call to tls_sockets() that the ephemeral key is needed. This causes tls_sockets() to continue requesting additional packets until it receives the ServerHelloDone.
When the certificate signature algorithm is RSA-PSS and OpenSSL 1.1.1 is used $cert_sign_algo contains some trailing space characters, which causes the algorithm not to be recognized in the case statement. This PR fixes the problem by removing any trailing space characters from $cert_sign_algo.
This PR fixes a false positive in std_cipherlists(). Currently, sclient_success is not initialized (so it initially set to 0). If a server is being tested that only supports TLSv1.3, the --ssl-native option is not used, and run_protocols() is run before run_std_cipherlists(), then for many of the calls to std_cipherlists() no tests are run and so sclient_success remains at its initial value (0), which is treated as success (i.e., the server supports at least one of the ciphers in the list).
The reason this happens is that in the testing loop, the TLSv1.3 test is skipped if the list of ciphers doesn't include any TLSv1.3 ciphers (and only the "Strong encryption" test includes TLSv1.3 ciphers) and the tests for each of lower versions of SSL/TLS is skipped since it was already determined in run_protocols() that those versions weren't supported.
This PR adds a check for TLSv1.3 support to run_protocols(), checking for support for the final version of TLSv1.3 (0x0304) as well as drafts 18, 19, 20, and 21 (0x7F12, 0x7F13, 0x7F14, and 0x7F15).
This PR is a continuation of #833.
With additional testing with different options I encountered more places where $OPENSSL was printing "WARNING: can't open config file: /usr/local/etc/ssl/openssl.cnf" where testssl.sh was not suppressing the error message.
This PR redirects stderr to /dev/null or to $ERRFILE for several more calls to $OPENSSL in order to suppress these warning messages.
For ciphers that use the ChaCha20-Poly1305 cipher, LibreSSL shows "Enc=ChaCha20-Poly1305" in the "openssl ciphers -V" command rather than "Enc=ChaCha20(256)" and for some GOST ciphers it shows "Enc=GOST-28178-89-CNT" rather than "Enc=GOST(256)". This causes a problem for neat_list() if information is being obtained from "$OPENSSL ciphers -V" rather than from the cipher-mapping.txt file.
If testssl.sh is used with OpenSSL 1.1.1 and TLSv1.3 support is enabled, then the check for whether the server has a cipher order will always fail. The problem is that since the call to s_client doesn't specify a protocol a TLSv1.3 ClientHello will be sent. However, the call specifies a list of ciphers that doesn't include any TLSv1.3 ciphers. So, OpenSSL will fail with the error: "No ciphers enabled for max supported SSL/TLS version." The solution is to add the "-no_tls1_3" option.
This PR fixes the problem by taking advantage of the recently-added s_client_options() function. It adds a "-no_tls1_3" option whenever:
* $OPENSSL supports TLSv1.3
* The command line doesn't specify any protocol: -ssl2, -ssl3, -tls1, -tls1_1, -tls1_2, or -tls1_3.
* The command line includes the -cipher option
* The list of ciphers that will be sent doesn't include any TLSv1.3 ciphers.
Add TLSv1.3 support to run_cipher_per_proto()
Fix branch
This PR adds support for TLSv1.3 to run_server_preference(). It only provides partial support, as it only works if the support supports and earlier TLS protocol (in order to determine whether the server has a cipher order). It also will only show TLSv1.3 as the "Negotiated protocol" if $OPENSSL supports TLSv1.3.
This PR also fixes a bug in which the variable "proto" was defined as used as both a regular variable and as an array.
If run_server_preference() is performed
* against a server that supports SSLv3 and that does not have a cipher order; and
* using a version of OpenSSL that does not support SSLv3; and
* with the --mapping option set to "rfc" or "no-openssl"
then the "Negotiated cipher per proto" will not show the SSLv3 cipher since cipher[i] will be empty.
This PR addresses issue #660 for run_rc4(), ensuring that support for RC4 ciphers is detected even if no RC4 ciphers are supported with the highest protocol that the server supports.
This PR adds support for TLSv1.3 to run_std_cipherlists().
This PR also provides a partial fix for #660 - addressing the issue only for run_std_cipherlists(). Rather than testing the server once for each cipher list, it tries the server once for each protocol supported by the server. This makes the testing more robust, but adds significantly to the time it takes to perform the tests.
This PR addresses issue #660 for run_sweet32(), detecting if 3DES is used, even if it isn't used with the highest protocol version supported by the server. As with PR #854, this increased robustness comes at the expense of taking addition time to run the test.
In client_simulation_sockets() and tls_sockets(), don't work to create a SOCK_REPLY_FILE that contains the entire server's response (in cases where the response was spread across multiple packets) unless $DEBUG is at least 1.
I believe there is a typo in the second definition of DEBUG_ALLINONE. If I run testssl.sh using the -x option for bash I get the following error:
testssl.sh: line 12714: -false: command not found
This PR adds initial support for TLSv1.3 to tls_sockets() and for run_client_simulation(). It does not change any of the other functions test TLSv1.3. So, with the exception of run_client_simulation(), the functionality added by this PR can only be tested using the --devel option.
This PR does not include the ability to decrypt the encrypted portions of the server's response. So, it does not support functions that need to see such things as the server's certificate, status information, or extensions (other than key share).
This PR fixes the use of has_server_protocol() in two places.
Currently std_ciphersuites() only tries SSLv2 if the server is known to support SSLv2. This changes it to try SSLv2 unless the server is known to not support SSLv2.
In run_beast(), tests against the server are run to determine support for TLSv1.2, TLSv1.1, TLSv1, and SSLv3 unless the server is known to support that protocol (i.e., even if has_server_protocol() reports that the server does not support the protocol). This changes it so that a test is only performed against the server if has_server_protocol() reports that it doesn't know whether the protocol is supported.
In the data provided by https://api.dev.ssllabs.com/api/v3/getClients, Chrome 57 Win 7 and Firefox 53 Win 7 send ClientHellos that indicate support for TLSv1.3 draft 18, but the highest_protocol for each of these is specified as 0x0303. The result is that if the server being tested supports TLSV1.3 draft 18, `run_client_simulation()` will incorrectly report "No connection" for these servers since the DETECTED_TLS_VERSION (0x0304) will be higher than the specified highest_protocol.
This PR fixes the problem by changing the highest_protocol to 0x0304. Note that another solution to this problem would be to change the ClientHello messages for these two browsers. It is my understanding that TLSv1.3 is disabled by default for these browsers, so presumably the ClientHello messages would not specify TLSv1.3 support if they were configured with TLSv1.3 support disabled.
This may not be specific to LibreSSL, but just my local setup. However, when I test using LibreSSL testssl.sh still prints the following message several times:
WARNING: can't open config file: /usr/local/etc/ssl/openssl.cnf
This PR suppresses the error message for several calls to $OPENSSL and so fixes the problem.
This is an initial implementation of the idea I proposed in #791. It includes checks based on draft-ietf-tls-grease as well as checks for specific implementation bugs that have previously been encountered.
This code needs testing. While I know of one server that will fail if the ClientHello contains more than 128 ciphers, I haven't been able to test any of the other code against any servers that have the tested-for bugs.
In addition, there is a need for polishing. The tests are referred to as `--grease`, which may not be a very user-friendly name. In addition, there is no output providing information about what tests are being performed. If a server fails a test, then a warning message is printed and is sent to `fileout()`. If the server passes all of the tests, then there is just a single output of "No bugs found."
At the moment, the code is not run by default. Unless `-g` or `--grease` is explicitly included in the command line, the code in this commit is not executed.
Currently the call to `$OPENSSL s_client` to obtain the certificate returned by the server when SNI is not provided is in `certificate_info()`, which means that it is called once for each certificate found the various called to `get_server_certificates()`.
This PR moves the call to `$OPENSSL s_client` to `run_server_defaults()` so that the call is made only once, even if more than one server certificate was found.
In addition, in most cases the certificate returned by the server when SNI is not provided will already have been retrieved by `run_server_defaults()` (in rounds 8-14), in which case `$HOSTCERT.nosni` can just be copied from there rather than making an additional call to `$OPENSSL s_client`.
testssl.sh produces an invalid JSON file if the --json-pretty option is used with the --single-cipher option. The reason is that fileout_section_header() isn't called before run_cipher_match() calls fileout() and fileout_section_footer() is not called afterwards.
There is also a problem with MEASURE_TIME, since the "cleanup" at the end of lets_roll() is not performed.
This PR fixes these problems by adding a call to fileout_section_header() before the call to run_cipher_match() and by copying the code from the end of lets_roll() to run_cipher_match() (just before the call to exit).
Currently, when `$DEBUG` is 2 and the connection is successful, `parse_tls_serverhello()` prints out information about the server's ephermal (EC)DH key, but nothing else. For example:
```
sending client hello... reading server hello...
dh_bits: ECDH, P-256, 256 bits
sending close_notify...
(183 lines returned)
```
This commit changes `parse_tls_serverhello()` so that information about dh_bits is only displayed if `$DEBUG` is at least 3, making it the same as for other information about the server's response.
In addition, it indents the printing of the information about dh_bits in order to better align with other information displayed at this debug level.
Update `$TLS12_CIPHER` to contain only 128 ciphers (so that it will work with servers that can't handle larger ClientHello messages), and also add some newer ciphers to `$TLS12_CIPHER`. Also define a `$TLS12_CIPHER_2ND_TRY` containing a list of 127 ciphers that do not appear in `$TLS12_CIPHER`. `$TLS12_CIPHER_2ND_TRY` is used in `run_protocols()` in order to perform a second test against servers that do not establish a TLSv1.2 connection when offered `$TLS12_CIPHER`.
In `run_protocols()` for TLS 1.2, try one set of 127 ciphers and if the result isn't a connection at TLSv1.2 then try another set of 127 ciphers before giving up and assuming that TLS 1.2 isn't supported.
The data for `run_client_simulation()` currently includes two clients that send version 2.0 CLIENT-HELLO messages (see Appendix E.2 of RFC 5246). Each of the CLIENT-HELLO messages advertises support for newer protocol versions (SSLv3 in the case of IE6XP and TLSv1.0 in the case of Java 6u45). A server may reject one of these version 2.0 CLIENT-HELLO messages, or it may respond with an SSLv2, SSLv3, or TLSv1.0 ServerHello.
The current code in `client_simulation_sockets()` assumes that the server's response with be an SSLv3 or later ServerHello. So, it can support cases in which servers respond with an SSLv3 or TLSv1.0 ServerHello (once PR #800 is accepted to undo the mistake in PR #797), but not cases in which servers response with an SSLv2 ServerHello.
This PR adds code to `client_simulation_sockets()` to check if the server's response is an SSLv2 ServerHello, so that it can process such responses with `parse_sslv2_serverhello()` rather than `parse_tls_serverhello()`.
When a connection is made using SSLv3 or later, `run_client_simulation()` will show to the protocol and cipher selected for the connection. With this PR, if the connection is made using SSLv2, `run_client_simulation()` will just show "SSLv2." In the case of SSLv2, the ServerHello contains a list of all ciphers that the server and client have in common, and it is up to the client to choose one. So, if the client and server have more than one cipher in common, more information about the client would be needed to know which cipher it would choose.
`std_cipherlists()` uses `has_server_protocol()` to determine whether to test for ciphers using SSLv2. However, this was resulting in false negatives due to #759. This PR removes the `has_server_protocol()` check so that SSLv2 is checked whenever the connection attempt with the TLSv1.2 ClientHello failed.
This PR fixes the extraction of the cipher suites in SSLv2 ClientHellos in `client_simulation_sockets()`. Since `client_simulation_sockets()` can only handle SSLv3 and above ServerHellos, it removes any SSLv2 ciphers and converts the other cipher from 3-byte format to 2-byte format.
This PR adds the same additional check to `client_simulation_sockets()` as was previously added to `tls_sockets()`. It extracts the list of cipher suites offered from each ClientHello and passes the list to `parse_tls_serverhello()` so that `parse_tls_serverhello()` can check that the cipher offered in the ServerHello was included in the ClientHello.
This assumes that a real client would abort the connection if it was presented with a cipher in the ServerHello that it didn't offer in its ClientHello.
According to a discussion thread on the IETF TLS WG mail list (see https://www.ietf.org/mail-archive/web/tls/current/msg19720.html), there is at least one TLS server that will fail if the last extension in the ClientHello has contains extension_data of length 0.
Currently, `tls_sockets()` will create such a ClientHello if:
* The padding extension is included, and the length of the ClientHello without the padding data would be between 508 and 511 bytes.
* No padding extension is included, and the caller provided `$extra_extensions` in which the last extension in `$extra_extensions` is empty.
* No padding extension is included, `$extra_extensions` is empty, no ECC cipher suites are offered, and the ClientHello is for TLSv1.1 or below (in this case the next protocol extension would be that last one).
This PR avoids the server bug (in nearly all cases) by ensuring the the padding extension (when present) always contains at least one byte, and by ensuring that when the padding extension is not present that the (non-empty) heartbeat extension is the last extension.
This PR does leave one possible scenario in which the last extension would be empty. If the caller provides an `$extra_extensions` in which the last extension in `$extra_extensions` is empty, `tls_sockets()` does not add a padding extension (or a padding extension is included in `$extra_extensions`), and `$extra_extensions` includes a heartbeat extension, then the last extension in the ClientHello would be empty. This, however, is a highly unlikely scenario, and certainly there are currently no such calls to `tls_sockets()` in testssl.sh.
As reported in #782, some servers will return a ServerHello with a cipher not listed in the ClientHello rather than than return an Alert, if the server does not support any of the ciphers listed in the ClientHello.
This commit modifies `tls_sockets()` to check whether the cipher in the ServerHello was one included in the ClientHello and to fail if it wasn't.
In `run_hpkp()` there is a call to `$OPENSSL s_client` that uses `${sni[i]}` as one of the command line options, but `sni` is not defined. My guess is that this was a copy/paste error from `run_client_simulation()`, which is the only function where an `sni` array is defined.
I am guessing that the intention was to use `$SNI` in `run_hpkp()`.
This PR attempts to address the outstanding issues with respect to issue #733, mainly by addressing the rules for when a certificate is obtained without SNI.
I believe I discovered the reason for issue #757: https://github.com/drwetter/testssl.sh/commit/f2303a0d79bc6f5c21181c0ed08ef5135abbeeeb.
This commit removed attempted to replace `$cbc_cipher_list_hex` (which was computed on the fly) with `$cbc_ciphers_hex` (which is static). However, the function was still using `$cbc_cipher_list_hex`, and since it wasn't being initialized to "" at the beginning of the function, the second call to `run_beast()` (to handle the second IP address) just appended to the value created by the first. Then, when the first two bytes were removed from the resulting string the result was a malformed cipher suite list, which caused `tls_sockets()` to fail.
This PR implements the suggestion from #753 for a child process in mass testing to send a signal to the parent to exit if the child encounters an error parsing its command line. At the moment, the child only sends the signal if it encounters an error that results in the `help()` function being called, but that could easily be changed (e.g., to also send a signal if `fatal()` is called in the child process).
In the case of parallel mass testing, the cleanup function needs to call `get_next_message_testing_parallel_result()` for the child that sent the signal, since otherwise the child's error message would not be displayed. Since I cannot tell which child sent the signal, I just call `cleanup()`, which displays the output of all completed child processes. Since the child process will send the signal almost immediately after starting, it can be assumed the that process that send the signal will be the last one that completed, and so its output will be displayed last (so it isn't hidden from the user).
Note that PR #753 is still needed, since there are still scenarios in which a child would not produce any JSON output, but the parent testssl.sh would not exit (e.g., the child process cannot open a socket to the server it is supposed to test). In additional, PR #754 would still be useful, since it would be more user friendly to catch the error in the mass testing file immediately (when possible) rather that partway through a potentially time-consuming testing process.
There is a bug in testssl.sh that occurs if mass testing is being performed, there is an error in the command line for one of the child tests, and either a single HTML file or a single JSON file is being created.
If mass testing is being performed and `parse_cmd_line()` detects an error in the command line for one of the child tests, then it will call `help()`, which will exit the program, resulting in `cleanup ()` being called. `cleanup ()` will call `html_footer()` and `fileout_footer()`. Since `html_header()` and `json_header()` have not yet been called, `$HTMLHEADER` and `$JSONHEADER` will both be `true, and so `html_footer()` and `fileout_footer()` will output HTML and JSON footers, even though no headers have been output.
This PR fixes the problem by having `help()` set `$HTMLHEADER` and `$JSONHEADER` to `false` so that no HTML or JSON footers are created.
A related problem is that if a single JSON file is being created, the parent process will insert a separator (a comma) into the JSON file between the outputs of each child process. However, if there is an error in one of the child process's command lines, then this child process will not produce any JSON output and so the JSON file will have two consecutive separators (commas), which is invalid according to http://jsonlint.com.
This PR provides a partial fix for the problem for parallel mass testing by checking whether a child process has created a non-empty JSON output before adding a separator to the JSON file. It leaves two unresolved problems:
* It does not fix the problem at all for `run_mass_testing()`, where the separator is added before the test with the command line error is run.
* It does not fix the problem for parallel mass testing for the case in which the first child test has a command line error.
This PR introduces the following changes/improvements to running mass testing in parallel:
* Continuous feedback is provided on the progress of testing, so that testssl.sh doesn't appeared to be frozen, even if it is waiting a long time for a child test to complete. [The feedback text is sent to `stderr` so that it doesn't appear in the log file if the `--logging` option is used.]
* Text sent to `stderr` by a child test is captured and then displayed in context with the appropriate test rather than being displayed at the time the error occurs. [Note that this means that if the `--logfile <logfile>` option is used (with `logfile` being the name of a file), then `logfile` will include both `stdout` and `stderr`.]
* If a test is started but it does not complete (because testssl.sh was stopped or because the test timed out), then a message is displayed indicating that the test didn't finish.
I believe that `run_mass_testing_parallel()` is either ready for use or nearly ready for use. So, I changed the program to use `run_mass_testing_parallel()` rather than `run_mass_testing()` if the `$EXPERIMENTAL` flag is set.
When the `--log`, `--logging`, or `--logfile <logfile>` option is being used and testssl.sh is stopped, a "printf: write error: Broken pipe" message tends to appear. From what I can tell, this is a result of the `tee` process being killed before the `cleanup ()` function completes. At the moment, `cleanup ()` doesn't write very much to `stdout`, but if parallel mass testing is performed, then `cleanup ()` may try to write the results of several previously completed tests.
This PR fixes the problem by adding the `-i` option ("ignore interrupt signals") to `tee`.
Note that I have tested this on a Linux desktop and an OS X laptop, but don't have a MS Windows computer on which to test this change.
This PR provides improvements to `run_mass_testing_parallel()`. Currently, `run_mass_testing_parallel()` treats `$MAX_PARALLEL` as the maximum difference between the number of the test whose results were last processed and the number of the most recently started test. This means that test #40 will not be started until the results of test #20 have been processed. I've encountered situations in which tests 21 though 39 have completed, but test #20 is still running, and so no new tests are started.
This PR fixes the problem by checking the status of all running child tests to see if any are complete, rather than just looking at `$NEXT_PARALLEL_TEST_TO_FINISH`. This prevents one slow child test (or a few slow child tests) from slowing up the entire mass testing process.
This PR also changes the basis for determining whether a slow child process should be killed. Rather than waiting `$MAX_WAIT_TEST` seconds from the time that the parent started waiting (which is rather arbitrary), it kills the process if `$MAX_WAIT_TEST` seconds have passed since the child test was started. Given this, and that the above change makes it less likely that a slow child test will slow up the overall testing, I increased `$MAX_WAIT_TEST` from 600 seconds to 1200 seconds.
I added some `debugme` statements that provide feedback on the status of testing, but in non-debug mode there may be a perception issue. If one test (e.g., test #20) is very slow, testssl.sh will not display any results from later tests until the slow test finishes, even though testssl.sh will continue running new tests in the background. The user, seeing no output from testssl.sh for an extended period of time, may think that testssl.sh has frozen, even though it is really just holding back on displaying the later results so that the results will be displayed in the order in which the tests were started.
There is a comment in the `run_client_simulation()` function that says "FIXME: printf formatting would look better, especially if we want a wide option here."
This PR is an attempt at addressing that FIXME and adding a wide option. The proposed wide option prints the same information as the non-wide option, just with the columns aligned. I didn't add any of the additional information that is displayed by other functions in wide mode, since I thought that made the output too wide.
* Changed calls to testssl.sh to not include `--quiet` or `--append` flags. Modified perl script to remove HTML header and footer before comparing to terminal output.
* Changed `TERM_WIDTH` to 120 (doesn't affect test, but 80 created too much line wrapping).
* Replace date and time information with X's rather than removing entirely. This should not affect the comparison, but will make the output created displayed in an error message look closer to the actual output of testssl.sh
I've never programmed in perl before, but this script seems to work. It includes two checks:
* I runs testssl.sh without the `--debug` flags and checks that the HTML file is the same as what is sent to the terminal.
* It runs testssl.sh with `--debug 4` and checks that the HTML file created is the same as the one created without the `--debug` flag.
`emphasize_stuff_in_headers()` only adds color to the text being printed to the terminal if `$COLOR` is 2. So, the same should be the case for the HTML output.
This PR addresses issue #616, changing `run_cipher_match()` so that only those ciphers that are available are shown, unless the `--show-each` flag has been provided.
It also fixes a problem where the signature algorithm isn't being shown, even if `$SHOW_SIGALGO` is true.
This PR just addresses some places where quotes need to be used to avoid word splitting in case the referenced file, or path to the file, contains space characters.
The previous fix did not work if testssl.sh was found via `$PATH`. This seems to work in all cases. If testssl.sh is found via `$PATH` or if the command line includes a path, then `which` returns a non-empty response; otherwise, `$0` does not include any path, but one needs to be provided, so `$RUN_DIR/$PROG_NAME` is used.
Using "$0" as the name of the executable seems to work as long as "$0" contains a directory name (e.g, "workingfiles/testssl.sh"), but not if it is just the name of the executable (e.g., "testssl.sh"). Specifying "$RUN_DIR/$PROG_NAME" seems to work in both cases, since if "$0" doesn't contain any path information, `$RUN_DIR` is `.`
Use the suggestion "If you want to print the argument list as close as possible to what the user probably entered" from http://stackoverflow.com/questions/10835933/preserve-quotes-in-bash-arguments to create `$CMDLINE` and to print the command lines in `run_mass_testing()` and `run_mass_testing_parallel()`.
